Common questions.
How is this different from pasting my draft into a chatbot like ChatGPT or Claude?
Fair question, and honestly the first one we asked ourselves. We know how much of yourself goes into a proposal. If a few prompts could give it the read it deserves, we would have shared them and gone back to our own research. We are researchers ourselves, and we built GrantPanel to help researchers.
Here is the difference. A chatbot gives you one model's reading, and a single model, however well prompted, tends to agree with the framing it is handed. GrantPanel convenes a mock review panel instead: a team of more than a dozen purpose-built AI agents, each with its own role, tools and data, working independently, then together, to judge your proposal on your funder's own criteria.
Not one model, and not one company's. A chatbot runs on a single company's model. GrantPanel uses different models from two companies, OpenAI (ChatGPT) and Anthropic (Claude), and the two catch different kinds of errors. Each stage runs on whichever model did it best when we tested both on real proposals whose outcomes we know.
GrantPanel was developed with, and repeatedly revised on the advice of, former federal program managers, experienced panel reviewers, and faculty researchers at several universities. They ran their own proposals through it and told us what a real panel would have done differently.
In short: The value is in the engineered process, not a single prompt, and in the people behind it. GrantPanel grew out of real departmental mock review panels, and its founder has written, won and reviewed federal proposals. You watch the panel work live, you get three runs per proposal, and your proposal is never trained on and is deleted when the review finishes. More than a dozen purpose-built AI agents, on models from both OpenAI and Anthropic, do the work: each run checks compliance, any budget you upload, every reference, the current literature and prior funded work, adds a technical analysis, has three independent reviewers argue over three rounds, and ends with a chair who keeps dissent and a recommended fix for every weakness.
Item by item:
- A panel you can watch. Follow your run live, stage by stage: the literature searches as they go out, the three reviews as they are written, and the panel's argument round by round.
- Three runs per proposal. Runs 2 and 3 read your revised draft against what the earlier run found, so you see which concerns you addressed and what moved.
- Never trained on, and deleted. Unlike a personal chatbot account, which may use your conversations to train future models, your proposal is never used for training, by us or by our providers, and it is deleted the moment the review finishes.
- More than a dozen purpose-built agents. Each agent has one job and the tools and data that job needs, not a chatbot's defaults: reference indexes for your citations, live literature search for the state of the field, and federal award databases for prior funded work.
- Models from two companies, not one. Different models from OpenAI (ChatGPT) and Anthropic (Claude), which catch different kinds of errors, each stage on whichever did it best when we tested both on real proposals whose outcomes we know, and never downgraded to cut costs.
- Your funder's own criteria and scale. Read from your solicitation and the agency's own review frame (NSF, NIH, DOE, DOW, NASA, USDA, DOT), with pre-proposals judged at their stage. Any other call is reviewed on its stated criteria, rated on GrantPanel's own 1-5 scale, labeled as ours.
- Compliance and solicitation fit. Required sections, page and format limits, required sub-headings and attachments, the triggers for a return without review; then whether the proposal answers the call: its priorities, eligibility and required plans.
- A budget check. When you upload a budget, every sum is computed in code and held to the call's ceiling, cost-sharing and indirect-cost rules, and to the work the narrative describes.
- Every reference looked up. Each cited work is checked in Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex and Crossref, with retracted works and preprints marked.
- A deep literature search. Your novelty claims are checked against the field as it stands, with a live search that includes Europe PMC and arXiv, not just what a model remembers.
- Prior funded work. Related awards from NSF Award Search, NIH RePORTER and USAspending.gov, so the panel sees what is already funded and how yours differs.
- A technical analysis. Before the panel meets, an expert reader in your field checks the key claims, the math, every figure and table, the methods and the feasibility.
- Three independent reviewers. Each works in its own context and files a complete review before any other position exists, so none takes its cue from the others.
- Three rounds of panel discussion. Positions, counter-points and final votes: reviewers push back or concede with evidence, and a turn that only repeats its review is sent back.
- A chair who keeps dissent. The consensus says where the panel agreed and, under Points of disagreement, where it did not, instead of averaging the readings into one.
- A recommended revision for every weakness. The steps, the passage as it stands, and suggested wording where the fix is wording, with every quoted passage checked against your text. GrantPanel never edits your document.
- Findings you can trace. Every finding points to the page and passage it comes from, and the full deliberation transcript comes with the report.
- Your whole package, read in full. Up to 200 pages across the proposal, the solicitation and supporting documents, each page as text and as an image, so figures, tables and signed letters are read too. An optional document you leave out is noted as not supplied, never counted as a weakness.
- Exports for co-PIs and your research office. Save the report as PDF or HTML with the sections you choose, and a compliance checklist as PDF or CSV for Excel.
What happens to my proposal, and is it stored anywhere?
We are researchers ourselves, and we would not hand our own unpublished work to a tool that kept it. Your proposal and supporting files are held only while the review runs and are deleted automatically the moment it finishes. The solicitation is kept for your proposal's 60-day revision window, so revision runs need not upload it again. Beyond the solicitation, only the panel's written report is kept, in your account, so you can revise and run a revision review, and you can delete it at any time. Your files are never used to train models, by us or by our providers.
Do I need a finished proposal before I run it?
No, and waiting for one is the easiest way to lose the review's value. One proposal comes with three runs, so the first can be a mostly complete draft. The panel reviews it as the proposal you would submit, so its findings are the ones a real panel would raise, and you still have time to act on them. Fix what it finds, run it again, and keep the third run for the week before submission. The three runs share a 60-day window that opens on the first, so start about two months before your deadline.
What counts as a run, and how long do I have to use all three?
A run is one complete panel: compliance and solicitation alignment, a reference check, a deep literature search, prior funded work, a technical analysis, three independent reviewers, three rounds of deliberation, a chaired consensus, and recommended revisions. One proposal buys three of them. Runs 2 and 3 read your revised proposal against what the earlier run found, so you see what moved, which is why the first run can be a draft rather than the final version. Nothing counts down while a proposal sits unused, so you can buy well before you are ready. The first run opens a 60-day window, and the other two are yours at any point inside it. Sixty days is deliberately longer than most revision cycles: it is meant to cover reading the panel's findings, rewriting, and running again before your deadline, without becoming an allowance you bank indefinitely against a different submission.
Which agencies does it support?
Any program with a written solicitation. NSF, NIH, DOE, DOW, NASA, USDA, and DOT each get their own review frame: the funder's criteria, its rating scale, and its decision, such as NIH's 1-9 impact score, NASA's adjectives and relevance, DOE Early Career's 1-6 rating, NIFA's ranking, SCRI's relevance points, or a DOW BAA's select or do not select. Your call's own criteria and scale come first, except that NSF reviews always use NSF's own ratings. Foundations, institutional competitions, and any other call are reviewed on the criteria the call states, rated on GrantPanel's own 1-5 scale, labeled as ours.
Can my university or department pay?
Yes, with a purchasing card. Checkout runs on Stripe and takes a university p-card like any other card. Each purchase comes with an invoice and a receipt, with your department's name and address on them if you add them, for your records or for reimbursement.
For a whole department. A department, centre or research office can buy a block of proposal codes, at least ten, from its own GrantPanel account under Proposal codes, at less per proposal than buying them one at a time. It sends each colleague a code, from that page or by email from GrantPanel, and each colleague redeems it into their own account. The office sees whether and when each code was used, never the proposal or its report. Proposal codes are a prepaid purchase by your institution for its faculty. Each code must be used (its proposal's first run started) within one year of purchase. Until 30 days after that date, we refund any code that hasn't been used, at the price paid; after that, unused codes lapse.
By purchase order. Purchase orders are for proposal codes. If your department pays by purchase order, email hello@grantpanel.ai for a quote for a block of codes. We invoice your institution, and the codes are added to your account once it is paid.
Tax-exempt. Sales tax is charged only on purchases billed to a Texas address. If your institution is tax-exempt and pays with its own funds, email us its exemption certificate (Texas Form 01-339, or a university purchase voucher) before you buy: we mark your account tax-exempt, no tax is charged at checkout, and the invoice notes the exemption. Bought before sending it? Send it now and we refund the sales tax on that purchase. Paying by purchase order, send the certificate with the order and the invoice is issued without the tax.
Vendor setup. If your purchasing office needs to set GrantPanel up as a vendor, we send a W-9 and the details it asks for.
Can I try it before I pay?
There is no free run: every run is a full panel and costs the same to run either way. What you can do first is read a full sample report, in the same form yours will take, for a fictitious proposal. And your first paid proposal is covered: if its review doesn't help, tell us within 14 days of its first run, before you start its second, and we refund it in full, sales tax included.
Will GrantPanel write or edit my proposal?
No. It never edits your document. For each weakness, the report says how to fix it: the steps, the sentence as it stands, and suggested wording where the fix is wording. Where the fix is research content (your aims, methods, or results), it says what to write and the question to answer first, and leaves the writing to you. NIH, for one, does not consider applications substantially developed by AI to be the applicants' original ideas.
Can I use it on a proposal I'm reviewing for an agency?
No. Upload only work you wrote, or that its authors have authorized you to submit. A proposal assigned to you for review is confidential, and NIH and NSF both bar reviewers from uploading proposals to AI tools. The same goes for a colleague's proposal without their permission.
Will it predict my score?
No, and the distinction matters, because you will see ratings in your report. Each reviewer scores your proposal on the scale your solicitation states, or else on the funder's own (NSF's adjectives, NIH's 1-9 impact score, DOE's and NASA's scales), or else on GrantPanel's own 1-5 scale, labeled as ours, and the chair records where the panel came out. Those are this panel's judgement of this reading of your draft, and they are there for a reason: they are how you tell whether a revision actually moved anything. What they are not is a forecast. A real panel turns on who is assigned your proposal, what else is in the pile that day, and how the discussion goes on the morning. GrantPanel is practice, not prophecy: read the rating as a signal about your draft, not an estimate of your odds.
Why is the review so strict?
On purpose. Before submission, a tougher read than you are likely to get is the more useful one, because every weakness it finds is one you can still fix. Your actual review may be milder, and its outcome depends on the reviewers assigned, the other proposals in the panel, and the funds available.
Is there independent evidence that an AI review is worth reading?
Yes. Independent research finds AI pre-submission review can match or beat strong human reviewers, for example on journal articles. In an October 2026 Harvard working paper, researchers compared AI-written reviews of 124 draft research papers with reviews from paid expert reviewers. Three former journal editors, not told that any review was AI-written, preferred the AI review in 26 of 30 judgments.
Other 2026 work points the same way. In a peer-reviewed cardiology journal, two editors who did not know which reviews were which rated the AI reviews higher overall on 40 manuscripts. When the AAAI-26 conference added an AI review to each of nearly 23,000 submissions, more of the participants surveyed found it useful than not.
Those studies used a single AI review. GrantPanel gives your proposal a full panel: three independent reviewers who argue over three rounds, on your funder's own criteria, while you can still act on what it finds.
Can it review a white paper, concept paper, or pre-proposal?
Yes. The panel recognizes a preliminary submission and judges it at its stage: against the call's rules for that stage, with the stage's own decision, such as invite or not invite. Documents the call asks for only with a full proposal are not expected.
What do I upload?
PDFs. Your proposal and the solicitation are required; on a revision run the solicitation is already on file. The proposal is one PDF: only the project description is required, and the rest of the package goes in the same file if you have it, such as the summary, references, letters, biosketches, current and pending support, budget documents, and facilities and equipment. You can also add up to 10 supporting PDFs, such as related articles or reviews from an earlier submission. One run reads up to 200 pages in all, and the upload page keeps a tally as you go.
What if my program has no written solicitation, only a web page?
Save or print the program's web page as a PDF and upload it as the solicitation. If the page states review criteria, the panel uses them; if not, it falls back to the funder's general criteria, or else GrantPanel's own.
How long does a review take?
A full run (compliance and alignment, the reference, literature, and prior-funding checks, a technical analysis, three reviewers, three rounds of discussion, and the summary with its recommended revisions) usually takes about 5 to 15 minutes. Most of that time is the deep literature search: the panel checks your novelty and prior-work claims against the current literature instead of relying on what a model already remembers. We could return a report in seconds by skipping that step and save API credits and costs, but it would cost the technical depth and rigor that make the review worth reading.
Can I share the report with my co-PIs?
Yes. Export it as a PDF, or as an HTML file that opens in any browser, and send it to whoever you like. They don't need a GrantPanel account.
What does the technical analysis check?
Before the panel meets, a technical analyst, a senior researcher in your field, reads every page, figures and tables included, and checks your technical case: the claims, the math, and the arithmetic, which it runs rather than eyeballs. It does not rate the proposal. The reviewers read its findings, and the report prints them.
Which AI models run my review?
Models from both OpenAI (ChatGPT) and Anthropic (Claude), not one model with default settings. The two catch different kinds of errors, so each stage of the panel runs on whichever model did that stage best when we ran both providers through the full review on real proposals whose outcomes we know, scored against the weaknesses already documented in them. We follow both providers' releases, and a newer model goes through the same test before it replaces one. GrantPanel is independent and is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by either company.
Why not use cheaper or open-weight models to bring the price down?
We tested them extensively, across the whole pipeline. Smaller and open-weight models handle the mechanical stages competently: spotting a missing section, checking a page limit, extracting citations. Where they consistently fall short is the part that makes a review worth reading. They summarize a proposal instead of interrogating it, agree with each other instead of holding distinct positions through three rounds of argument, miss the gap between what a claim asserts and what the cited evidence actually supports, and produce weaknesses too generic to act on. A cheaper review isn't a bargain if its findings are ones you could have written yourself. So your review runs on a mixture of models from OpenAI (ChatGPT) and Anthropic (Claude), each stage on the model that did it best when we tested both providers on real proposals, with frontier models for the reviews, the debate, and the chair's synthesis. None is ever downgraded to cut costs. We would rather charge honestly for that than quietly serve you a weaker panel.
Other tools charge less. Why does GrantPanel cost more?
Some do, and if what you want is a quick read-through of your draft, one of them may suit you. GrantPanel is doing a different amount of work. Every run is a full panel of more than a dozen purpose-built AI agents: compliance and solicitation alignment, a reference check, a deep literature search, prior funded work, a technical analysis, three independent reviewers, three rounds of deliberation, a chaired consensus, and recommended revisions. Each stage is its own model call, not a single pass over your document. The most expensive part is the deep literature search: it queries the current literature on every run rather than relying on what a model happens to remember, and that search is a real cost we pay each time. We also move to newer frontier models as they are released instead of settling on an older, cheaper generation to protect our margin. For a proposal that represents years of work, and at a fraction of what a human grant consultant charges for the same read: we would rather be worth the price than be the cheapest.
Why is there no subscription?
Because we are from academia and we know the work is not continuous. Proposal writing arrives in bursts around solicitations and deadlines, and in between you are teaching, running a lab, reviewing, and doing the research itself. A monthly fee would quietly bill you through every month you never open the tool. So you buy a proposal review when you have your proposal ready, an unused proposal review never expires, and nothing charges you for the semesters you do not need us.
What if GrantPanel doesn't help?
Your first paid proposal is covered. If its review doesn't help, email us within 14 days of its first run, before you start its second, and we refund it in full, sales tax included. After that, a run that fails is returned to you automatically, and a report that misread your proposal is refunded or credited (see the Refund Policy). For a report that fell short, write to hello@grantpanel.ai with the proposal and solicitation you submitted and the report you received: your files are deleted after each run, so we'll need you to send them again.
Can I upload patient data or controlled material?
No. A narrative describing a clinical study is fine; the data behind it is not. Do not upload identifiable human-subject data, patient records, controlled unclassified information, or ITAR, export-controlled, or classified material. We do not sign BAAs.
Can my university license GrantPanel?
Yes. Research-development teams can contact hello@grantpanel.ai for institutional access, privacy review, and purchasing.
Is GrantPanel affiliated with a funding agency?
No. GrantPanel is an independent preparation tool. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to any funding agency or foundation.
Why are your reviewers called A, B and C?
Because nobody needs to see “Reviewer 2” before their Monday coffee. (All three read the whole proposal.)
Put your proposal in front of our panel first.
Upload your proposal and the agency's solicitation, and get a full simulated panel review in about 5–15 minutes.
Launch price: $59 a proposal through March 31, 2027, up to 3 runs, so start with your draft. No subscription required. See pricing →