AGENCY COVERAGE

Which agencies the panel actually knows.

A mock panel is only useful if it judges you against the right rulebook. Where an agency publishes standard review guidance, the panel applies it alongside your specific call. Where none exists, your call is the rulebook.

Native: NSF's review is built in: PAPPG-aware compliance, Intellectual Merit and Broader Impacts, and NSF's ratings, plus your call's own criteriaFunder frame: the funder's own criteria, rating scale and decision line are built in; your call's stated criteria and scale come firstFrom your solicitation: the panel extracts your call's stated criteria, required sections and format rules, and rates on GrantPanel's own 1-5 scale, labeled as ours, unless the call states one
AgencyTypical mechanismsCriteria the panel appliesSource
NSFNational Science Foundation
Standard research grants, CAREER, MRI, preliminary proposals, and most Directorate solicitations
Intellectual Merit and Broader Impacts in the PAPPG structure, plus the criteria the solicitation adds; NSF's ratings, split where a reviewer sits between two; CAREER's own rules; preliminary proposals judged at their stage
NativePAPPG + your solicitation
NIHNational Institutes of Health
R01, R21, R03, K-series, and the common F awards
NIH's Simplified Review Framework for research grants (Factors 1 and 2 scored 1-9, Factor 3 sufficient or not), the fellowship criteria for F awards, and for K awards and older notices the notice's own criteria; overall impact 1-9, where 1 is best
Funder frameNIH's framework + your notice
DOEDepartment of Energy
Office of Science FOAs, the Early Career Research Program, BER/BES/ASCR program calls, and other DOE offices
Office of Science merit criteria in the order your FOA ranks them, on DOE's 10-1 scale; Early Career on its 1-6 rating, with leadership potential; program policy factors as context; other DOE offices on the call's own criteria
Funder frameDOE's scales + your FOA
DOWDepartment of War (formerly DoD): DARPA, ONR, ARO, AFOSR, CDMRP
BAAs, white papers, and CDMRP award mechanisms
The BAA's stated criteria in its stated order; basic research BAAs end in Select or Do not select, DARPA in Selectable or Not selectable; CDMRP peer review on CDMRP's score bands (programmatic review is not simulated)
Funder frameDOW's decisions + your BAA
NASAROSES and directorate calls
ROSES program elements and Appendix-specific calls
Intrinsic merit, relevance (a proposal judged not relevant is not selectable) and cost, as your element states them; NASA's adjectival ratings, findings labeled Major or Minor, the panel's rating as the reviewers' median, and an audit of dual-anonymous proposals
Funder frameNASA's scale + your element
ERCEuropean Research Council
Starting, Consolidator, Advanced, and Synergy Grants
The criteria your call states — for ERC, ground-breaking nature, feasibility, and PI capacity as the call defines them
From your solicitationYour call's stated criteria
USDA NIFAAFRI, SCRI, and program-specific RFAs
AFRI Foundational and Applied Science, Education and Workforce programs, and SCRI pre-applications
AFRI's review criteria for your project type, on NIFA's reviewer scale and ranking (Outstanding to Do not fund); SCRI pre-applications on SCRI's industry relevance review, 0-100 points; other RFAs on their stated criteria
Funder frameNIFA's rules + your RFA
DOTFHWA, FRA, FTA, FAA, and other DOT agencies
Research BAAs, NOFOs, and concept papers
The notice's own criteria in its stated order, on its stated rating scale with any factor floors it sets; concept papers and white papers judged at their stage
Funder frameYour notice's scale
Private foundationsSloan, Simons, Moore, HHMI, Wellcome, and similar
Investigator awards and program grants where the call publishes criteria
The foundation's published criteria where it states them; otherwise general merit, feasibility, and fit to mission
From your solicitationVaries by call
Anything elseAny solicitation you can upload
Institutional seed funding, state programs, industry calls, internal competitions
The panel reads the solicitation you provide and derives its criteria from it, with no published standard to fall back on
From your solicitationFrom your upload

Your call's own criteria and rating scale come first, then the funder's general ones, and only then GrantPanel's own. NSF is the exception on scale: its own Excellent-to-Poor ratings always apply. Working from your solicitation alone is not a weaker review: the panel holds you to what the call itself says and nothing more, and the reviews themselves are unchanged.

DEFINITIONS

What “compliance checked” actually means.

Four different things get called compliance. GrantPanel does the first three and is explicit that it cannot do the fourth.

We do thisStructural compliance

Required sections present and correctly named, page and character limits, font and margin rules, required sub-headings, and the attachments the solicitation demands, plus the funder's own application rules (NSF's PAPPG, NIH's page limits, AFRI's instructions) where the call states none. These are the return-without-review triggers. Only a mandatory rule can be violated; a document you did not upload is not verifiable, never a violation.

We do thisSolicitation alignment

Whether the proposal answers the call it claims to answer: programme priorities addressed, eligibility conditions met on the face of the document, and required elements like data management or mentoring plans actually present and substantive.

We do thisBudget check

When you upload a budget or budget justification: each year's lines against their totals, F&A against its rate and base, the years against the cumulative page, the call's ceiling, duration, cost-sharing and indirect-cost rules, and the budget against the effort and purchases the narrative describes. A numerical flag shows its figures and any other cites the document, so each can be checked by hand; a figure it cannot read is marked not verifiable, never guessed. A budget you did not upload is noted as not supplied, never held against the proposal.

We cannotInstitutional certification

Approving the budget and its rates, committing cost sharing, subaward paperwork, conflict-of-interest disclosures, and the sponsor-facing certifications only your research office can sign. The budget check helps that review; nothing in a GrantPanel report substitutes for it.

REQUESTS

Your agency is not on the list.

Run it anyway — upload the solicitation and the panel will work from it directly. Then tell us which agency it was. What we tune next is driven by what people actually submit.